Commonwealth Journal

Local News

March 20, 2014

Board: Girdler’s infraction ‘unintentional’

Somerset — A state board has found that Somerset Mayor Eddie Girdler unintentionally violated a campaign finance law.

The Kentucky Registry of Election Finance has referred the case, which began in February when Alice Ping sent a formal complaint to the KREF, to the department’s executive director and general council for further review.

“There’s nothing in the records that would indicate it was an intentional or knowing violation of the law,” said Emily Dennis, general counsel with the KREF.

Ping, wife of local real estate developer Brook Ping, who is also a “unified government” leader, alleged in the complaint that Girdler personally helped pay for the printing and distributing of Pulaski County High School winter sports schedules for the 2013-2014 season but failed to include the “paid for by” statement.

“Girdler asserts that he believed the advertisement in question was exempt from the disclaimer requirement because it does not expressly advocate his election to the office of mayor,” states the registry’s staff report, submitted by Dennis after Thursday’s hearing. “Girdler makes a good faith argument, as the dual-sided advertisement does not overtly solicit a vote, a campaign contribution, or reference Girdler’s 2014 candidacy.

“However, it is clear that Girdler intended for his mayoral campaign to receive a political advertising benefit from the advertisement’s publication, as he used the Girdler Campaign Fund to pay for the advertisement and received a box of calendars for distribution,” the report continues.

According to KRS 121.190(1), “all newspaper or magazine advertising, posters, circulars, billboards, handbills, sample ballots, and paid-for television or radio announcements relating to the candidacy of any person for public office include a disclaimer indicating by whom the cost of the material was paid.” Alice Ping states in her complaint that the basketball schedules — which are small enough to fit into a billfold or pocket and can be folded and unfolded — violate that statute.

The front and back of the schedules have “Mayor Eddie Girdler” in bold, with the phrase “Thanks to every parent, family member, and friend for supporting our students and athletes.”

Girdler reported the $300 cost of the schedules, which came out of his campaign fund and not out of city funds, to the KREF. A search of Girdler’s campaign finances on the KREF website (www.kref.state.ky.us) for the upcoming May 20 primary election, reported as of Dec. 31, 2013, shows that Girdler paid out a total of $378.84 out of his campaign account, which was shown as having an ending balance of $6,831.16.

Girdler is running for re-election and will be facing off against current City Councilor Jim Rutherford and local businessman Alan Keck in the May 20 primary election. The top two vote-getters will move on to the November general election.

The issue boils down to the size of the schedules. According to KRS 121.190, “disclaimers shall not be required for calling cards smaller than three and one-half (3 1/2) inches by five (5) inches ...”

When the schedules are folded, they don’t exceed the 3 1/2 by 5 inches. But when unfolded, the committee found that the schedules measure out to be 4 inches by 5 inches — one-half inch over the minimum size.

Girdler, in his March 11 response to the original complaint, stated that once he was made aware that the calendars would exceed the three and one-half inches by five inches if unfolded, he destroyed all of the remaining schedules in his possession “with the exception of two that I am safekeeping should they need to be produced at a later date.”

Girdler in his response also said he “respectfully” sought guidance from the KREF “with regard to the issue presented.”

Dennis said a civil penalty will be handed down in the case. She pointed out that the case would have mandated a criminal penalty and would have been referred to the Kentucky Attorney general’s office if Girdler was found to have knowingly violated campaign finance laws.

Civil penalties may include a fine of up to $5,000.

Girdler didn’t attend Thursday’s hearing because he was out of the state. Attorney Charles Cole represented him in the case.

When reached by phone Thursday afternoon, Girdler called the complaint a “ridiculous accusation” — the same phrasing he used when discussing the issue earlier this week with the Commonwealth Journal.

“I’m very pleased and honored to be helping the kids of Somerset and Pulaski,” said Girdler. “Unfortunately, there are some people who feel instead of looking at those things, they look at ways of trying to make accusations out of it.”

Girdler emphasized that the violation was an unintentional one on his part.

Ping, through email, explained why she filed the complaint about the pocket schedules.

“My purpose in filing the complaint regarding the schedule cards was to see if the City of Somerset was paying for Pulaski County Basketball team schedule cards with Eddie Girdler’s name,” Ping said. “ ... now we know by way of KREF who paid for the PC Basketball Schedule cards and it was not the city.”

This is the second complaint Ping has filed against Girdler in recent weeks. The KREF on Feb. 28 received a formal complaint from Ping alleging Girdler of vote-buying.

Ping’s vote-buying complaint was based on a decision by Somerset City Council, handed down during the Jan. 13 city meeting, to offer a one-time $30 credit to city utility customers — those that use city water, sewer, and/or natural gas — who live in the city. They also voted to offer a one-time $15 credit to natural gas customers located outside the city limits. The $15 credit also applied to Ferguson residents currently receiving a city utility service.

The offer didn’t apply to businesses.

Ping has also taken issue with recent advertisements, paid for by city money, that informed readers of city events but featured Girdler’s name, which she said “ ... was so dominant in the ads they were like a campaign ad.

 “I hope Eddie Girdler will stop promoting his campaign with city money like advertisements,” Ping continued.

Ping said Girdler “ ... wants to drive a wedge between the City of Somerset and the rest of Pulaski County.

“I think Somerset and the rest of the County need to get along and work together for everyone’s best interest,” added Ping. “Just because you do not live in the city of Somerset does not mean you are against the city. That is my major disagreement with Mayor Girdler. No one, including myself, is trying to take anything from the City of Somerset. That is just the Mayor’s political spin.”

Girdler during the Monday, March 10 Somerset City Council meeting said Ping “ ... is a county resident who believes that we shouldn’t give things to our residents but they can take everything we’ve got.”

1
Text Only
Local News
  • Corps: Lake water fees may be coming

    Sometime, maybe three or four years down the road, Somerset and other communities that use water out of Lake Cumberland will pay fees for water drawn out of the lake. And, if Wolf Creek Dam springs another leak, communities along the lake might have to pay the cost of repairs.

    August 1, 2014

  • eubank school1.jt.jpg New cafeteria coming soon to Eubank Elementary

    Students at one elementary school in northern Pulaski County will be taking their lunches in the classroom for a bit while construction to its cafeteria continues. 

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • DOWNTOWN FLOWER FOTO.JPG Downtown beautification project underway

    No flowers yet, but the boxes are taking shape. A city beautification project is under way downtown and already completed are four elevated flower boxes –– three along the south side of the square in front of First and Farmers National Bank and one on the east side in front of Citizens National Bank’s downtown headquarters.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Rift over firefighter pay finally history

    Somerset officials are closing the books on a years-long disagreement between the city and the state labor cabinet over overtime pay and other benefits for firefighters and EMS workers. 

    July 31, 2014

  • BURNSIDE LODGE-TURNER FOTO.jpg Turner to meet with commissioner on Burnside Island

    A state representative unhappy over secrecy surrounding possible privatization of General Burnside Island State Park said he will respond positively to an invitation to meet with Elaine Walker, commissioner of Kentucky Tourism, Arts and Heritage Ca

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • Derek Kissee.jpg Science Hill man charged in Rockcastle County beating

    A Science Hill man has been accused of beating and leaving another Pulaski County man for dead in an abandoned Rockcastle County rock qu

    July 29, 2014 2 Photos

  • Kingsford Fire 07-29-2014 KS 09.jpg No injuries, minimal damage at Kingsford Plant

    A normal production day at the Kingsford Charcoal Plant in southern Pulaski County was halted for a few hours while firefighters worked to put out a small blaze at the plant. 

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • 020313 SCC Rogers BLdg-0286.jpg SCC tabbed as one of top places to work

    A national publication dedicated to all things secondary education has named Somerset Community College one of the best in the nation to work for. 

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Warning: Robo phone scam targeting local residents

    Authorities are warning local residents of a possible phone scam.

    July 28, 2014

  • Baskin Robbins Reopens 07-29-2014 JT 17.jpg Baskin Robbins is back in Somerset

    Even with two Dairy Queens, a new Orange Leaf and an ice cream truck, Somerset residents have still been screaming for more ice cream.

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

News Live
AP Video
Renewed Violence Taking Toll on Gaza Residents 2 Americans Detained in North Korea Seek Help US Employers Add 209K Jobs, Rate 6.2 Pct House GOP Optimistic About New Border Bill Gaza Truce Unravels; Israel, Hamas Trade Blame Raw: Tunisia Closes Borders With Libya Four Rescued From Crashed Plane Couple Channel Grief Into Soldiers' Retreat WWI Aviation Still Alive at Aerodrome in NY Raw: Rescuers at Taiwan Explosion Scene Raw: Woman Who Faced Death Over Faith in N.H. Clinton Before 9-11: Could Have Killed Bin Laden Netanyahu Vows to Destroy Hamas Tunnels Obama Slams Republicans Over Lawsuit House Leaders Trade Blame for Inaction
Facebook
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Stocks